Trading in Legal Claims

Law, Policy & Future Directions 
in Australia, UK & US

- by Dr Vicki Waye - 

 

- Table of Contents -
(subject to change prior to publication)

Table of Cases

Table of Statutes

Ch 1: An Introduction to Markets for Legal Claims

Introduction

Markets

Alienability of Legal Claims

Access to Justice

 

Ch 2: Transferability of Legal Claims: Legal & Economic Theory

Introduction

Efficiency and Alienability of Legal Claims

A Market for Pre-Injury Claims

A Market for Post-Injury Claims

Can a Robust Market in Legal Claims be Established?

Normative Concerns Regarding a Market for Legal Claims

Access to Justice and Proliferation of Claims

Commodification of Justice

Adverse Impacts on Lawyer-Client Relationship

Protection of Ingenuous Claim Owners

Conclusion

 

Ch 3: Current Australian Framework

Introduction

Legal Claims as Transferable Property Rights

Broadening Avenues of Litigation Funding

Towards a Jurisprudence Balancing Access to Justice & Trafficking in Litigation

Position of Professional Litigation Funders

Claim Alienability

 

Ch 4: Current English Framework

Introduction

Access to Justice Policy in England

The Advent of Large Claims Management Companies

Capping of Costs, Success Fees and Insurance Premiums

Guidelines for Success Fees and ATE Premiums

Introduction of Fixed Recoverable Costs and Success Fees

Cost Estimates, Budgeting and Capping

Costs Limits and Access to Justice

Contingency Fees

Common Law Developments

Wanton and Officious Intermeddling and Trafficking in Claims

Litigation Funding

Broadening Exemptions to Prohibitions against 3rd Party Financing & Assignment

Common Law Position

Conclusion

 

Ch 5: Current American Legal Framework

Introduction

Maintenance and Champerty

Assignability

Usury

Markets for Legal Claims

 

Ch 6: Regulation of Markets for Legal Claims

Introduction

Regulation and Market Failure

Market and Monopoly Power

Externalities

Public Goods

Co-ordination Problems

Inequality of Bargaining Power

Information Asymmetry 

Bounded Rationality 

Unconscionability

Regulatory Options: Unconscionability, Info Asymmetry and Bounded Rationality

Mandatory Provision of Information

Mandatory Provision of Ex Ante Legal Advice

Licensing

Mandatory Cooling Off   

Default Rules and Codes of Conduct

Conclusion

 

Ch 7: Abuse of Process, Costs & Secondary Sales

Introduction

Abuse of Process

Costs

Obligations Upon Assignees

Secondary Sales

 

Ch 8: Conflict of Interest Between Claimholders,
Lawyers & Litigation Entrepreneurs

Introduction

Relationship Between Legal Practitioner and Claim Holder

Relationship Between Claim Holder and Litigation Funder

Multiple Claim Holders

Potential Collusion Between Legal Practitioner, Defendant and Funder

Free Rider Problems: Sharing of Risk & Recovery of Funder’s Success Fee

Dealing With Conflict of Interests Between Class Members

Duties to Court and Justice

Conclusion

 

Ch 9: Future Directions

 

Appendix

Bibliography